Quorum and abstentions
Who counts in the vote?
A rule can count the people needed to open a decision one way and the votes needed to pass it another way. Try both counts on a single rehearsal before you write the rule.
Start with the room
In the Sunday workshop example, nine people hold seats. Three vote Yes, one votes No, and two abstain. One person present recuses and two are absent. Both draft rules need five for quorum and leave the recused person out of the quorum headcount. Six eligible members are present, so both reach quorum.
Write what “majority” counts
Rule A requires more than half of votes cast. Yes and No add up to four, so three Yes votes pass.
Rule B requires more than half of eligible members present. It counts six people in the voting base, including the two who abstain. Four Yes votes would be required, so the same ballot falls short.
Votes cast · 3 of 4 passes. Eligible present · 3 of 6 falls short.
Rehearse the exampleCheck the edge cases
- A tie. More than half requires a whole vote above half. Two Yes votes out of four fall short.
- A fraction. If your draft needs at least two-thirds of eight votes cast, it needs six Yes votes. Five is below the threshold.
- A recusal. Decide separately whether a present recused member counts toward quorum and what your voting base includes. The lab lets you change the quorum rule without moving a recused person into the eligible voting base.
- No ballot. If everyone abstains, the lab reports no recorded decision, even if the headcount reaches quorum.
Use the lab to compare proposed wording. For an actual decision, check the rules that govern your group.